Latest

#ACMA probes channel 9’s pokies propaganda | Power index

Broadcast authority ACMA has commenced an investigation into comments made by Channel Nine rugby league commentators Ray Warren and Phil Gould, as fallout continues to spread from their anti-poker machine reform editorial.

An ACMA spokesman confirmed the investigation this morning, telling The Power Index that a statement would be released shortly.

Independent MP Andrew Wilkie and fellow anti-gambling campaigner Senator Nick Xenophon have also written a letter to Channel Nine demanding an explanation over the comments. 

Last week The Power Index reported that Clubs Australia was given advance notice by Nine that the editorial was going ahead. The lobby group said it did not pay Nine for the spot.

At the time Nine did not respond to questions about who commissioned the editorial. Today a spokesperson told The Power Index the network would be providing a “considered response” on the issues raised by Wilkie and Xenophon. The spokesperson did not return a second email asking about the ACMA probe in time for today’s deadline.

“We are confident we are not in breach of any code provisions,” a spokesperson said. “That said, we do not intend to offer a running commentary on the matter in the media.”

Warren and Gould have come under attack from Wilkie and Xenophon for the half time message in which they slammed mooted pre-commitment technology for poker machines.

Senator Xenophon says he is “still pretty stunned” by Warren and Gould’s comments which were “so clumsily worked into the commentary.”

“We need answers from the network about who actually authorised this,” he told The Power Index this morning. “Ray Warren says it was given to him as a job to do, the question is by whom.”

Yesterday Warren told Fairfax radio that he did community service announcements “regularly” and the September 23 editorial “was no different”. He said he believed the controversial policy could lead to job losses.

But the day after the match Warren co-hosted a Triple M sports show called Dead Set Legends, on which he revealed the comments were scripted, according to the Sydney Morning Herald.

”It was a directive from up top that it be read by at least somebody, so I read it,” Warren told co-host Dan Ginnane.

Warren said he supported the message and while he wasn’t sure, believed it was paid for:

”I think it was an ad, if you like, it sounded like an ad. I think it was done on behalf of the rugby league, who is fully supportive of the clubs.”

Those comments seem to contradict a letter to a complainant from Nine’s Network Compliance Manager Shelley Bates, who said the message was “purely the opining of the commentators” and “in no way an advertisement”.

According to Media Watch, Bates said: “The comments were part of the program content and were in no way an advertisement. Furthermore the Nine Network did not receive any payment or other benefits for the broadcast of the information.”

What is still unclear is how involved Phil Gould was in writing the remarks. In his response to Warren’s initial half time comments, Gould called mandatory pre-commitment a “rubbish policy” that “won’t work” and “will hurt.”

Gould is a key Penrith Panthers identity, having been recently installed as football operations manager. Last year the Penrith Leagues Club took home more than $90 million from poker machines.

Gould has also been staunchly anti-pokies reform. In a column published in July he wrote that mandatory pre-commitment technology was “not a policy designed to benefit the Australian people”.

Darin Sullivan's avatar
About Darin Sullivan (1964 Articles)
Former President of the Fire Brigade Employees’ Union (2009-2018) and a professional firefighter with more than 30 years experience. I live and work on the NSW South Coast, Australia. I am a strong advocate for firefighters and emergency service workers with an interest in mental health issues and caring for those around me. I am a former Director on the NSW Fire Brigades Death and Disability Super Fund and work with charities including ‘The Movember Foundation’. As a leader and activist I have long been active in the campaign for action on climate change. I am a Station Commander in the fire and rescue service in NSW and have 30 years experience fighting fires, both rural and urban. I am passionate about highlighting the impact climate change is having on fire preparedness and fire behaviour in Australia, and the risks associated with inaction on climate change. I am also a spokesperson for the Australian Climate Media Centre.